The Absolute Best Italian Restaurants in Del Mar, CA: Savor Authentic

As a Del Mar native, I’ve explored every corner of our coastal town to uncover the finest Italian cuisine that captures both heart and palate. The best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA, blend authentic recipes with Southern California’s fresh ingredients, offering everything from handmade pastas to wood-fired pizzas.

Whether you’re a local craving a comforting plate of lasagna or a tourist seeking a sunset view with your tiramisu, these nine establishments promise unforgettable meals. Each bite tells a story of tradition, creativity, and passion, served in settings that range from cozy patios to elegant dining rooms. Join me as I share my personal experiences, highlighting the flavors, service, and ambiance that make these spots shine for food lovers in San Diego.

Best Italian Restaurants in Del Mar, CA: A Local’s Guide to Authentic Italian Dining

As a Del Mar native, I’ve savored the rich flavors of Italian cuisine at some of the finest restaurants in our coastal town. Below, I share my top nine picks for the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA, each offering a unique blend of authentic dishes, warm hospitality, and unforgettable dining experiences. From oceanfront patios to cozy interiors, these establishments capture the essence of Italy while embracing Southern California’s fresh ingredients. Each review includes essential details, highlights, and my personal take on what makes these spots shine.

Aqua Mare Cucina Italiana

Address: 12955 El Camino Real, San Diego, CA 92130
Phone: 858-720-0100
Website: aquamaredelmar.com
Hours: Open from 4 PM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Exceptional seafood dishes with responsibly sourced ingredients
Signature homemade pastas crafted daily
Generous portions perfect for sharing
Stunning sunset views over Los Penasquitos Lagoon
Attentive service that elevates the dining experience

Have you ever dined where the ocean breeze complements every bite? Stepping into Aqua Mare Cucina Italiana, I was greeted by a charming and serene ambiance, with its enclosed patio offering breathtaking views of the Del Mar coastline. This top-ranked gem in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist instantly felt like a slice of Italy transported to California. The soft lighting and coastal decor set the stage for a memorable evening.

The menu is a celebration of impeccable flavors, with handmade pastas and seafood dishes stealing the spotlight. I indulged in their lobster ravioli, a culinary masterpiece where delicate pasta pockets burst with sweet, succulent lobster, paired with a creamy vodka sauce. For dessert, the limoncello tiramisu was a refreshing twist, its zesty notes balancing the rich mascarpone perfectly. The generous portions ensured I left satisfied, with leftovers to savor later.

One standout side was the Gorgonzola risotto, a velvety creation that paired creamy, cheesy goodness with a perfectly cooked filet. The risotto’s fresh ingredients and just-right texture left me in awe, as each bite melted in my mouth. It’s a dish that demands you slow down and savor every spoonful.

The staff at Aqua Mare is warm and attentive, making every guest feel like family. My server, Maria, was incredibly knowledgeable, recommending wine pairings that elevated the meal. When I requested a dairy-free option, she seamlessly accommodated my needs, ensuring a stress-free experience. Their hospitality is a hallmark of this restaurant’s charm.

For locals and tourists alike, Aqua Mare is a must-visit. Its unforgettable seafood, hearty portions, and impeccable service make it a standout in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or craving authentic Italian, reserve a table and soak in the coastal elegance.

CUCINA enoteca Del Mar

Address: 2730 Via de la Valle, Del Mar, CA 92014
Phone: 858-704-4500
Website: urbankitchengroup.com
Hours: Open from 4 PM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Innovative Italian dishes with California flair
Signature sweet pea cappelletti as a fan favorite
Family-style portions ideal for groups
Vibrant wine selection curated for pairings
Lively outdoor patio with a cozy vibe

What’s the secret to a perfect Italian meal in Del Mar? At CUCINA enoteca Del Mar, I discovered a vibrant and inviting space that ranks high on the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The open-air deck and equestrian-inspired decor, complete with toy horses strung along the staircase, create a playful yet sophisticated atmosphere that draws you in.

The food here is nothing short of spectacular, blending Italian tradition with Southern California’s bounty. The sweet pea cappelletti, a work of art, features delicate pasta filled with vibrant peas and ricotta, kissed by a light lemon butter sauce. For something sweet, the pistachio gelato was a creamy delight, its nutty depth lingering on my palate. The family-style portions are perfect for sharing, leaving everyone at the table content.

The burrata toast side dish was a revelation. Served with freshly baked artisan bread, the burrata was creamy and indulgent, topped with cherry tomatoes that popped with sweetness. The meticulous preparation made every bite a burst of flavor, earning gasps of delight from my dining companions.

The staff is friendly and engaging, with a knack for making you feel at home. Our server, James, was exceptionally attentive, offering insights into the menu and checking in just enough to ensure comfort. His enthusiasm for the dishes added a personal touch to the experience.

CUCINA enoteca is a gem for anyone seeking creative cuisine, generous servings, and a welcoming vibe. As a top contender in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist, it’s ideal for group gatherings or a cozy date night. Make a reservation and dive into this culinary delight.

Il Fornaio Del Mar

Address: 1555 Camino Del Mar, Del Mar, CA 92014
Phone: 858-755-8876
Website: ilfornaio.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Authentic Italian recipes rooted in tradition
Wood-fired pizzas with perfect crusts
Hearty portions for satisfying meals
Oceanfront views from the patio
Polished service with a personal touch

Can a meal transport you to Italy’s heart? At Il Fornaio Del Mar, I was enveloped by a warm and elegant ambiance, making it a standout in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The oceanfront patio, with its mesmerizing Pacific views, set a picturesque backdrop as I settled in for lunch.

The cuisine here is consistently excellent, with wood-fired pizzas and pastas that honor Italian heritage. The prosciutto and arugula pizza was a flavor symphony, its thin, crispy crust topped with salty prosciutto and peppery greens. The tiramisu, a classic, was velvety and indulgent, with espresso-soaked ladyfingers that melted in my mouth. The hearty portions ensured I left full and happy.

The wild arugula salad was a delightful side, featuring fresh greens, avocado, and a tangy lemon-olive oil dressing. The vibrant ingredients and balanced flavors made it a refreshing complement to the richer mains, leaving me impressed by its simplicity.

The staff is professional yet approachable, enhancing the dining experience. My server, Liliana, was charmingly attentive, offering thoughtful recommendations and ensuring my glass was never empty. Her warmth made the meal feel like a special occasion.

Il Fornaio is a must for locals and visitors craving authentic flavors, ample portions, and stunning views. A top pick in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist, it’s perfect for a romantic sunset dinner or a leisurely lunch. Book a table and savor the magic.

North Italia - One Paseo

Address: 1540 Camino Del Mar, Del Mar, CA 92014
Phone: 858-793-6467
Website: northitalia.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 10 PM daily

Highlights:

Handmade pastas crafted daily
Signature Bolognese with rich flavors
Shareable portions for group dining
Creative cocktails to complement meals
Welcoming service in a modern setting

Ever wondered where to find Italy’s soul in Del Mar? North Italia at One Paseo welcomed me with a sleek and inviting vibe, securing its spot in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The modern decor and open layout create a lively yet intimate setting perfect for any occasion.

The food is bold and flavorful, with handmade pastas taking center stage. The Bolognese, a rich and comforting classic, featured al dente tagliatelle coated in a savory meat sauce that lingered on the tongue. For dessert, the salted caramel budino was a decadent treat, its creamy texture offset by a crunchy biscotti crumble. The shareable portions made it easy to sample multiple dishes.

The arancini side was a standout, with golden, crispy rice balls filled with gooey mozzarella. The freshly prepared marinara added a bright, tangy note, making each bite irresistibly satisfying. It’s the kind of dish that sparks joy at the table.

The staff is engaging and attentive, elevating the experience. Our server, Sarah, was exceptionally warm, guiding us through the cocktail menu with enthusiasm. Her quick response to a special request made the meal feel personalized and effortless.

North Italia is a haven for those seeking fresh pastas, hearty servings, and a vibrant atmosphere. A top choice in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist, it’s perfect for a night out with friends or a cozy dinner. Stop by and indulge in its modern Italian charm.

Davanti Enoteca - Del Mar

Address: 12955 El Camino Real, San Diego, CA 92130
Phone: 858-519-5060
Website: davantienoteca.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Shareable small plates with bold flavors
Homemade focaccia as a crowd-pleaser
Perfect portion sizes for variety
Cozy patio with a relaxed vibe
Knowledgeable staff enhancing the meal

What makes an Italian meal unforgettable? At Davanti Enoteca, I was captivated by a cozy and rustic ambiance, earning its place in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The intimate patio and warm lighting create a welcoming retreat that feels like a hidden gem.

The menu shines with vibrant and creative dishes, particularly the shareable plates. The cacio e pepe, a masterful rendition, featured perfectly cooked spaghetti twirled in a creamy, peppery sauce that was both simple and profound. The panna cotta, silky and topped with seasonal berries, was a light yet luxurious finish. The well-portioned plates encouraged sampling without overwhelming.

The focaccia con formaggio, a warm and indulgent side, arrived puffed up and golden, stuffed with molten cheese. The freshly baked bread and rich filling made it a table favorite, with everyone reaching for seconds. It’s comfort food at its finest.

The staff is gracious and informed, making every visit special. Our server, Luca, was genuinely enthusiastic, sharing stories behind the dishes and suggesting perfect wine pairings. His attention to detail ensured a seamless dining experience.

Davanti Enoteca is a treasure for locals and tourists craving flavorful small plates, balanced portions, and a charming setting. A standout in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist, it’s ideal for a relaxed evening of sharing and savoring. Visit and discover its rustic allure.

Ambrogio15 Del Mar

Address: 12841 El Camino Real, San Diego, CA 92130
Phone: 858-925-6261
Website: ambrogiodelmar.com
Hours: Open from 12 PM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Michelin-starred chef curating the menu
Paper-thin pizzas with unique toppings
Sustainable ingredients for fresh flavors
Sophisticated wine list by Gambero Rosso
Elegant service in a modern space

Can a pizza redefine fine dining? At Ambrogio15 Del Mar, I stepped into a sleek and refined space, a highlight of the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The modern decor and open layout at Skydeck create an upscale yet approachable vibe that’s perfect for special occasions.

The cuisine, crafted by a Michelin-starred chef, is nothing short of extraordinary. The truffle pizza, a delicate masterpiece, featured a paper-thin crust topped with earthy truffle and creamy burrata. For dessert, the chocolate hazelnut tart was a decadent delight, its rich filling balanced by a crisp shell. The thoughtful portions left me satisfied without feeling stuffed.

The caprese salad side was a standout, with vibrant heirloom tomatoes and creamy mozzarella drizzled in aged balsamic. The fresh, sustainable ingredients shone through, creating a refreshing and elegant dish that complemented the richer mains.

The staff is polished and attentive, elevating the experience. My server, Sofia, was exceptionally knowledgeable, explaining the sourcing of ingredients with passion. Her recommendations made the meal feel curated and special.

Ambrogio15 is a must for those seeking gourmet pizzas, fresh ingredients, and top-tier service. A star in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA topl dévelop, it’s perfect for a refined night out. Reserve a spot and experience its Michelin-worthy magic.

Villa Capri Cucina Italiana

Address: 3870 Valley Centre Dr, San Diego, CA 92130
Phone: 858-793-0999
Website: villacaprirest.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Classic Italian comfort food with heart
Signature lasagna layered with flavor
Hearty portions for family dining
Cozy interior with a homey feel
Friendly service that feels personal

What’s the recipe for Italian comfort? At Villa Capri Cucina Italiana, I was enveloped by a warm and homey ambiance, securing its spot in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The cozy dining room, with its soft lighting and rustic touches, feels like a family kitchen in Italy.

The food is soul-warming and robust, with classic dishes that hit all the right notes. The lasagna, a towering masterpiece, was layered with rich Bolognese, creamy béchamel, and melted mozzarella, delivering pure comfort. The cannoli, crisp and filled with sweet ricotta, was a nostalgic treat. The hearty portions made it ideal for sharing with loved ones.

The minestrone soup side was a revelation, packed with fresh vegetables and simmered to hearty perfection. The slow-cooked broth and tender veggies created a bowl of warmth that felt like a hug, earning smiles around the table.

The staff is genuinely warm and attentive, treating guests like family. Our server, Antonio, was charmingly engaging, sharing stories about the recipes and ensuring our needs were met. His personal touch made the meal unforgettable.

Villa Capri is a haven for locals and visitors craving comforting classics, generous servings, and a homey vibe. A beloved pick in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist, it’s perfect for family dinners or cozy nights out. Stop by and savor the warmth.

Buonasera New York Pizzeria

Address: 12873 El Camino Real, San Diego, CA 92130
Phone: 858-350-5811
Website: buonaserapizzeria.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Authentic New York-style pizzas with bold flavors
Signature meatball sub as a hearty favorite
Large slices perfect for quick meals
Casual, family-friendly atmosphere
Fast, friendly service for dine-in or takeout

Craving a slice of New York in Del Mar? Buonasera New York Pizzeria welcomed me with a lively and casual vibe, earning its place in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The no-frills decor and bustling counter create a fun, laid-back setting that’s perfect for families or a quick bite.

The menu delivers bold, authentic flavors, with New York-style pizzas as the star. The pepperoni pizza, a classic done right, featured a thin, crispy crust loaded with spicy pepperoni and gooey cheese. The chocolate chip cannoli was a sweet surprise, its crunchy shell bursting with creamy filling. The large slices are a meal in themselves, perfect for a satisfying lunch.

The garlic knots side was a standout, with pillowy dough tied into knots and brushed with fragrant garlic butter. The freshly baked bites, served with marinara, were addictively delicious, sparking joy with every dip.

The staff is fast and friendly, keeping the energy high. Our server, Mike, was cheerfully efficient, ensuring our order arrived hot and fresh. His enthusiasm for the pizza made the experience even more enjoyable.

Buonasera is a go-to for locals and tourists seeking authentic pizza, hearty slices, and a fun vibe. A top pick in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist, it’s ideal for a casual meal or takeout. Grab a slice and experience New York in Del Mar.

Piatti

Address: 2182 Avenida De La Playa, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-454-1589
Website: piatti.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Freshly rolled pastas made daily
Signature Cacio e Pepe with perfect balance
Shareable portions for communal dining
Charming patio with a neighborhood feel
Warm, attentive service that shines

What’s the essence of a great Italian meal? At Piatti, I was greeted by a charming and cozy ambiance, a gem in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist. The shaded patio and trattoria-style interior create a welcoming neighborhood vibe that feels like home.

The cuisine is fresh and soulful, with hand-rolled pastas stealing the show. The Cacio e Pepe, a timeless classic, was flawlessly executed, with al dente spaghetti coated in a creamy, peppery sauce that danced on the tongue. The lemon ricotta cake, light and zesty, was a refreshing finale. The shareable portions made it easy to enjoy a variety of dishes.

The bruschetta side was a highlight, featuring toasted artisan bread topped with vibrant tomatoes and basil. The fresh ingredients and careful preparation created a bright and flavorful bite that set the tone for the meal.

The staff is warm and attentive, making every guest feel valued. Our server, Emma, was delightfully knowledgeable, offering pairing suggestions and checking in with a genuine smile. Her care elevated the entire experience.

Piatti is a treasure for locals and visitors craving fresh pastas, generous servings, and a cozy setting. A standout in the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA toplist, it’s perfect for a relaxed lunch or intimate dinner. Visit and savor its trattoria charm.

A Culinary Journey Worth Taking

My journey through Del Mar’s Italian dining scene reveals nine restaurants that elevate every meal into a celebration. From the Michelin-starred artistry at Ambrogio15 to the hearty comfort of Villa Capri, each offers distinctive flavors and warm hospitality. These are places where memories are made, whether you’re sharing generous portions with friends or savoring a solo slice at Buonasera. For locals and visitors, this San Diego Nav guide to the best Italian restaurants in Del Mar, CA, is your invitation to indulge in authentic cuisine and coastal charm. Visit these gems and discover why Del Mar is a haven for Italian food lovers.