The Absolute Best Pizza in Encinitas: Top 10 Must-Try Spots

As a proud Encinitas local, I’ve savored countless slices to uncover the finest pizza spots that make our coastal town a foodie haven. Whether you’re a visitor craving a memorable meal or a resident seeking a new favorite, Encinitas delivers vibrant flavors and unforgettable dining experiences. From wood-fired Neapolitan pies to classic New York-style slices, each pizzeria on this toplist offers something special.

What makes a pizza truly exceptional? For me, it’s the perfect crust, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming vibe that turns a meal into a moment. My journey through Encinitas’ pizza scene, from cozy family-run spots to lively modern joints, showcases the best this town has to offer. Join me as I share my top 10 picks, complete with must-try dishes and insider tips for every pizza lover.

Blue Ribbon Artisan Pizzeria

Address: 897 S Coast Hwy 101, Encinitas, CA 92024
Phone: 760-634-7671
Website: blueribbonpizzeria.com
Hours: Open from 12 PM to 9 PM daily
Highlights:
- Exceptional wood-fired pizzas with a perfect crust
- Unique topping combinations, like rosemary potato chicken
- Generous portions for sharing
- Flavorful appetizers, such as burrata with balsamic
- Welcoming, family-friendly service

What makes a pizza experience unforgettable in Encinitas? Stepping into Blue Ribbon Artisan Pizzeria, I was greeted by a cozy, inviting atmosphere that instantly set the tone for a memorable meal. The aroma of wood-fired pizza wafted through the air, promising something extraordinary. As the top pick in my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza spots, Blue Ribbon delivers a dining experience that’s hard to beat.

The quality of the food here is nothing short of remarkable. Their wood-fired pizzas are a standout, with a thin, crispy crust that achieves the perfect balance of chewiness and char. The Margherita is a classic, boasting vibrant tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella that melts in your mouth, while the Rosemary Potato Chicken pizza is a creative masterpiece, blending earthy rosemary with tender chicken and roasted potatoes. The generous portions ensure everyone leaves satisfied, whether dining solo or with a group.

One appetizer that stole my heart was the burrata with balsamic reduction. The creamy, dreamy texture of the burrata, paired with crusty bread and a tangy balsamic drizzle, was a revelation. Each bite felt like a luxurious treat, with the fresh ingredients shining through in a way that left me speechless. It’s the kind of starter that elevates the entire meal.

The service at Blue Ribbon is equally impressive. The staff is warm, attentive, and knowledgeable, always ready to recommend a wine pairing or accommodate special requests. Their genuine enthusiasm for the menu made me feel right at home, enhancing the overall experience with their thoughtful care.

For locals and visitors craving an unforgettable pizza experience, Blue Ribbon Artisan Pizzeria is a must-visit. With its stellar wood-fired pizzas, creative toppings, and impeccable service, it’s no wonder this gem ranks at the top of my Encinitas pizza toplist. Stop by and indulge you won’t be disappointed.

Buona Forchetta - Encinitas

Address: 250 N Coast Hwy 101, Encinitas, CA 92024
Phone: 760-704-0600
Website: buonaforchettasd.com
Hours: Open from 12 PM to 9 PM daily
Highlights:
- Authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas with a thin crust
- Signature Luigina pizza with porcini and prosciutto
- Hearty portions perfect for groups
- Delectable appetizers, like calamari fritti
- Friendly, engaging service

Ever wondered what authentic Italian pizza tastes like in Encinitas? Walking into Buona Forchetta, I was enveloped by a vibrant, welcoming ambiance that felt like a slice of Italy. As the second gem on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza places, this spot delivers a soulful dining experience.

The pizzas here are exceptional, with a Neapolitan-style crust that’s thin, pliable, and perfectly charred. The Margherita is a crowd-pleaser, with sweet tomato sauce and springy mozzarella that elevate simplicity to art. The Luigina pizza, topped with earthy porcini mushrooms and salty prosciutto, is a bold, innovative creation that showcases their culinary prowess. The generous portions make it ideal for sharing, leaving everyone at the table content.

The calamari fritti appetizer was a highlight, with a light, crispy coating that let the fresh, tender calamari shine. Paired with a zesty marinara, it was a delightful burst of flavor that had me savoring every bite. The high-quality ingredients made this dish a perfect complement to the pizzas.

The staff at Buona Forchetta is charming and attentive, ensuring every guest feels valued. Their expert recommendations and warm hospitality elevate the meal, making even special requests feel effortless. It’s the kind of service that turns a good meal into a memorable experience.

For anyone seeking authentic Italian flavors in Encinitas, Buona Forchetta is a top choice. Its Neapolitan pizzas, creative toppings, and outstanding service make it a standout on my toplist. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, this is a pizza haven you need to experience.

Corner Pizza

Address: 1955 San Elijo Ave, Cardiff, CA 92007
Phone: 760-943-8171
Website: cornerpizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily
Highlights:
- Crispy thin-crust pizzas with bold flavors
- Unique artichoke pesto pizza as a signature
- Satisfying portions for any appetite
- Standout mac and cheese with bacon
- Relaxed, friendly service

What’s the secret to a perfect pizza night in Encinitas? Corner Pizza welcomed me with a laid-back, inviting vibe that felt like a neighborhood gem. Ranking third on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza spots, this place offers a delightful escape for pizza lovers.

The pizzas are phenomenal, with a crisp, thin crust that delivers a satisfying crunch. The classic pepperoni is a hit, with zesty sauce and melty cheese that never disappoints. The artichoke pesto pizza, however, is a game-changer, blending vibrant pesto with tender artichokes for a creative, flavorful masterpiece. The hearty portions ensure no one leaves hungry, making it perfect for casual gatherings.

The mac and cheese with bacon was an unexpected star. The creamy, cheesy sauce paired with crisp bacon bits created a comforting, indulgent dish that had me in awe. The fresh ingredients and perfect preparation made every bite unforgettable.

The staff’s easygoing, friendly demeanor adds to the charm. They’re quick to assist and make every guest feel welcome, ensuring a relaxed dining experience. Their attentive service makes even busy nights feel seamless.

For locals and travelers alike, Corner Pizza is a must-try for its flavorful thin-crust pizzas, unique offerings, and warm service. This spot earns its place on my Encinitas pizza toplist as a go-to for a satisfying meal. Drop in and enjoy the magic.

Best Pizza & Brew - Cardiff

Address: 102 Aberdeen Dr, Cardiff, CA 92007
Phone: 760-436-3999
Website: bestpizzaandbrew.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily
Highlights:
- High-quality New York-style pizzas
- Signature Philly pizza with bold flavors
- Large portions ideal for sharing
- Craft beer selection to complement meals
- Efficient, courteous service

Craving a slice of New York in Encinitas? Best Pizza & Brew in Cardiff greeted me with a lively, energetic atmosphere that felt like a classic pizzeria. As the fourth spot on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza places, it’s a haven for pizza and beer enthusiasts.

The New York-style pizzas are outstanding, with a thin, foldable crust that’s both crisp and chewy. The classic cheese pizza delivers rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella in perfect harmony. The Philly pizza, loaded with savory steak and melty cheese, is a bold, creative triumph that packs a punch. The generous slices make it a great choice for groups or solo diners.

The fried zucchini sticks were a standout side, with a crisp, golden coating and tender zucchini inside. Paired with a tangy ranch dip, they were a delightful surprise that showcased the kitchen’s commitment to fresh ingredients. Each bite was crisp and flavorful, elevating the meal.

The staff is prompt and courteous, ensuring a smooth dining experience. Their knowledge of the beer menu and willingness to customize orders made the visit even more enjoyable, creating a welcoming vibe for all.

Best Pizza & Brew is a top pick for anyone seeking authentic New York-style pizza and a great craft beer selection in Encinitas. Its large portions and friendly service secure its spot on my toplist. Whether you’re local or visiting, this pizzeria is a must-visit.

Flippin Pizza

Address: 215 S El Camino Real, Encinitas, CA 92024
Phone: 760-632-1497
Website: flippinpizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily
Highlights:
- Classic New York-style pizzas with crispy crust
- Signature White Pie with ricotta and garlic
- Plentiful portions for value
- Fresh salads as perfect sides
- Prompt, welcoming service

What’s the key to a great pizza adventure in Encinitas? Flippin Pizza welcomed me with a bright, casual vibe that felt like a true pizzeria. Ranking fifth on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza spots, it’s a go-to for classic flavors and great value.

The New York-style pizzas are top-notch, with a crispy, edge-to-edge crust that’s both light and satisfying. The classic pepperoni is a crowd-pleaser, with bold sauce and melty cheese that hit all the right spots. The White Pie, topped with creamy ricotta and fragrant garlic, is a unique, flavorful creation that stands out. The large portions ensure everyone gets their fill.

The house salad was a refreshing surprise, with crisp greens, juicy tomatoes, and a zesty vinaigrette that tied it all together. The fresh, vibrant ingredients made it a perfect complement to the rich pizzas, leaving me impressed with its simplicity.

The staff’s warm, efficient service makes every visit a pleasure. They’re quick to assist and handle busy crowds with ease, creating a relaxed, welcoming environment that enhances the meal.

For pizza lovers in Encinitas, Flippin Pizza is a fantastic choice for its classic New York-style pies, fresh sides, and great service. It’s a worthy addition to my toplist and a spot I’d recommend to locals and tourists alike. Stop by for a slice of pizza perfection.

Forchettabouddit

Address: 345 S Coast Hwy 101, Encinitas, CA 92024
Phone: 760-452-6022
Website: forchettabouddit.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily
Highlights:
- Innovative gourmet pizzas with unique toppings
- Signature truffle pizza for bold flavors
- Generous portions for sharing
- Flavorful appetizers, like stuffed mushrooms
- Attentive, friendly service

What elevates a pizza night to extraordinary in Encinitas? Forchettabouddit welcomed me with a modern, inviting ambiance that promised something special. As the sixth spot on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza places, it’s a haven for gourmet pizza lovers.

The gourmet pizzas are exceptional, with a perfectly baked crust that’s both crisp and tender. The classic Margherita shines with bright tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella, while the truffle pizza, infused with earthy truffle oil and wild mushrooms, is a culinary masterpiece. The hearty portions make it ideal for group dining or leftovers.

The stuffed mushrooms appetizer was a standout, with juicy mushrooms filled with a savory cheese blend and baked to golden perfection. The fresh ingredients and rich flavors made it a memorable starter that paired beautifully with the pizzas.

The staff is engaging and attentive, offering personalized recommendations that elevate the experience. Their warm hospitality ensures every guest feels valued, making the meal even more enjoyable.

Forchettabouddit is a must-visit for anyone craving innovative pizzas and top-notch service in Encinitas. Its unique flavors and generous portions make it a standout on my toplist. Locals and visitors, head here for a gourmet pizza adventure you won’t forget.

Hammer’s NY Pizza

Address: 1991 Village Park Way, Encinitas, CA 92024
Phone: 760-753-7777
Website: hammersnypizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily
Highlights:
- Authentic New York-style slices with bold flavors
- Signature meat lover’s pizza for hearty appetites
- Large, shareable portions
- Tasty wings as a crowd-pleasing side
- Efficient, friendly service

Craving a true New York slice in Encinitas? Hammer’s NY Pizza greeted me with a classic, no-frills vibe that felt like a Big Apple pizzeria. Ranking seventh on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza spots, it’s a go-to for authentic flavors.

The New York-style pizzas are impressive, with a thin, foldable crust that’s crisp yet chewy. The classic cheese pizza delivers robust tomato sauce and melty cheese in perfect balance. The meat lover’s pizza, packed with savory sausage and pepperoni, is a hearty, indulgent creation that satisfies. The large slices are perfect for sharing or solo indulgence.

The buffalo wings were a standout side, with a spicy, tangy sauce and tender meat that hit all the right spots. Served with creamy ranch, they were a flavorful complement to the pizza, showcasing fresh preparation that left me impressed.

The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring a smooth dining experience. Their quick service and welcoming attitude make every visit enjoyable, even during busy hours.

Hammer’s NY Pizza is a top choice for authentic New York-style pizza and bold flavors in Encinitas. Its large portions and great service earn it a spot on my toplist. Locals and tourists, stop by for a slice of New York in California.

Leucadia Pizzeria & Italian

Address: 315 S Coast Hwy 101, Encinitas, CA 92024
Phone: 760-942-2222
Website: leucadiapizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily
Highlights:
- Coastal-inspired pizzas with fresh ingredients
- Signature Thai pizza for unique flavors
- Generous portions for value
- Fresh salads as vibrant sides
- Reliable, warm service

What makes a pizza spot a local favorite in Encinitas? Leucadia Pizzeria & Italian welcomed me with a bright, beachy vibe that felt quintessentially coastal. As the eighth spot on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza places, it’s a gem for unique flavors.

The coastal-inspired pizzas are outstanding, with a light, tender crust that’s perfectly baked. The classic Margherita shines with fresh tomatoes and creamy mozzarella, while the Thai pizza, topped with spicy peanut sauce and crisp veggies, is a bold, creative standout. The hearty portions ensure great value for any group.

The Caprese salad was a highlight, with juicy tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and a balsamic drizzle that was perfectly balanced. The vibrant ingredients made it a refreshing, delightful side that complemented the rich pizzas beautifully.

The staff is warm and reliable, offering prompt service and genuine smiles. Their attention to detail and ability to handle special requests make every visit feel personalized and enjoyable.

Leucadia Pizzeria is a top pick for unique, coastal-inspired pizzas and great value in Encinitas. Its fresh ingredients and friendly service make it a standout on my toplist. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this spot is a must-try for a flavorful meal.

East Coast Pizza

Address: 2015 San Elijo Ave, Cardiff, CA 92007
Phone: 760-944-1599
Website: eastcoastpizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily
Highlights:
- Authentic East Coast-style pizzas
- Signature Buffalo chicken pizza for bold flavors
- Satisfying portions for groups
- Crispy garlic knots as a tasty side
- Welcoming, efficient service

Wondering where to find East Coast vibes in Encinitas? East Coast Pizza welcomed me with a nostalgic, lively atmosphere that felt like a slice of home. Ranking ninth on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza spots, it’s a haven for classic flavors.

The East Coast-style pizzas are phenomenal, with a thin, crispy crust that’s perfect for folding. The classic pepperoni is a winner, with zesty sauce and melty cheese that hit all the right notes. The Buffalo chicken pizza, with its spicy sauce and tender chicken, is a bold, flavorful creation that stands out. The large portions make it great for sharing.

The garlic knots were a standout side, with a crisp exterior and soft, garlicky interior that melted in my mouth. Paired with a rich marinara, they were a delightful treat that showcased fresh preparation.

The staff is welcoming and efficient, ensuring a smooth, enjoyable experience. Their friendly demeanor and quick service make every visit feel effortless, even during peak hours.

East Coast Pizza is a must-visit for authentic East Coast-style pies and bold flavors in Encinitas. Its generous portions and great service secure its spot on my toplist. Locals and tourists, head here for a classic pizza experience.

Pandora’s Pizza

Address: 828 N Coast Hwy 101, Encinitas, CA 92024
Phone: 760-230-2323
Website: pandoraspizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily
Highlights:
- California-style pizzas with fresh toppings
- Signature seafood pizza with smoked salmon
- Ample portions for value
- Vibrant salads as fresh sides
- Friendly, attentive service

What’s the recipe for a perfect pizza outing in Encinitas? Pandora’s Pizza welcomed me with a colorful, modern vibe that felt like a culinary adventure. As the tenth spot on my toplist of Encinitas’ best pizza places, it’s a gem for fresh, local flavors.

The California-style pizzas are impressive, with a light, airy crust that’s both tender and crisp. The classic veggie pizza bursts with fresh produce and bright flavors, while the seafood pizza, topped with smoked salmon and asparagus, is a unique, coastal-inspired masterpiece. The generous portions ensure great value for any meal.

The house salad was a standout, with crisp greens, juicy tomatoes, and a tangy vinaigrette that was perfectly balanced. The fresh, local ingredients made it a refreshing complement to the pizzas, leaving me delighted.

The staff is friendly and attentive, offering personalized service that enhances the experience. Their warm hospitality and quick responses make every visit feel special and welcoming.

Pandora’s Pizza is a top choice for fresh, California-style pizzas and vibrant flavors in Encinitas. Its ample portions and great service make it a worthy addition to my toplist. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, stop by for a delicious, memorable meal.

Conclusion

In this guide, I’ve explored 10 pizzerias that define Encinitas’ pizza culture, each with unique flavors, generous portions, and stellar service. From Blue Ribbon’s artisan masterpieces to Pandora’s coastal-inspired creations, these spots cater to every palate. Locals and tourists alike will find something to love, whether it’s a creative topping combo or a classic Margherita. For the ultimate pizza adventure, trust San Diego Nav to guide you to these culinary gems. Grab a slice and discover why Encinitas is a pizza paradise.