The Absolute Best Pizza in La Jolla: Sizzling Slices Await

Growing up in La Jolla, I’ve chased the perfect pizza slice through sunlit streets and cozy corners, each bite a story of flavor and community. The quest for the best pizza in La Jolla isn’t just about food it’s about savoring moments with friends, family, or even a quiet evening by the coast. From wood-fired Neapolitan crusts to hearty New York-style slices, La Jolla’s pizza scene offers something for every palate.

I’ve handpicked 10 spots that blend authenticity, creativity, and warm hospitality, ensuring locals and visitors find their ideal meal. Whether you’re a tourist craving a beachside feast or a San Diegan seeking a new favorite, this guide, rooted in my lifelong love for my hometown, will lead you to unforgettable pizza experiences.

Top 10 Best Pizza Places in La Jolla: A Local’s Guide to Sizzling Slices

As a La Jolla native, I’ve savored countless pizza slices along our sun-kissed shores, from cozy beachside joints to upscale Italian gems. Below, I share my top 10 picks for the best pizza in La Jolla, each offering unique flavors and vibes. For each restaurant, you’ll find essential details, standout highlights, and my personal experience, crafted to guide locals and tourists alike to unforgettable meals.

Isola Pizza Bar

Address: 7734 Girard Ave, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-412-5566
Website: isolalj.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Authentic wood-fired pizzas crafted with imported Italian ingredients
Signature Neapolitan crust, light and perfectly charred
Generous portions for sharing with friends or family
Fresh antipasti, like crispy octopus, elevate the meal
Warm, attentive service that feels like family

What makes a pizza truly unforgettable in La Jolla’s vibrant food scene? Stepping into Isola Pizza Bar, ranked #1 on my toplist, I was greeted by a cozy, Mediterranean-inspired space with the irresistible aroma of wood-fired dough. The open kitchen and twinkling patio lights set a welcoming tone that promised something special.

The pizzas here are nothing short of spectacular, with a Neapolitan crust that’s airy yet crisp, showcasing Chef Massimo Tenino’s dedication to tradition. I tried the Hot Honey & Smoked Prosciutto, a culinary masterpiece balancing sweet, tangy, and salty notes, and the Margherita, where vibrant tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella sang in harmony. The generous portions left my table of friends fully satisfied, with leftovers to savor later.

The Crispy Octopus antipasti stole my heart as a side dish. Tender yet crisp, it’s paired with chickpeas and capers, bursting with fresh, coastal flavors that had me marveling at every bite. The preparation felt like a love letter to the sea, with ingredients so fresh they practically sparkled.

The staff at Isola are incredibly warm and knowledgeable, guiding us through the menu with enthusiasm. They seamlessly accommodated a friend’s gluten-free request, ensuring everyone felt cared for and included. Their attentive service elevated the evening, making it feel like a mini-vacation to Italy.

For pizza lovers and visitors seeking authentic flavors and hearty portions, Isola Pizza Bar is a must-visit. Its wood-fired perfection and stellar service make it a shining star in La Jolla’s pizza scene. Come for the pizza, stay for the vibes this is my top pick for a reason!

Piazza 1909

Address: 7731 Fay Ave, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-412-3108
Website: piazza1909.com
Hours: Open from 11:30 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Handcrafted pizzas baked in a wood-fired oven
Unique toppings, like gorgonzola and speck, for bold flavors
Hearty portions perfect for groups
Saffron risotto balls as a standout appetizer
Friendly, professional service in a historic setting

Can a historic beach house serve pizza that rivals Italy’s finest? At Piazza 1909, my #2 toplist gem, I entered a charming, nostalgic space housed in a 1909 building, with heated patios buzzing with energy. The rustic elegance and scent of fresh dough instantly captivated me.

The pizzas are impeccable, with a wood-fired crust that’s soft yet charred to perfection. The Gorgonzola, Zucca & Speck pizza, with its rich, creamy cheese and roasted butternut squash, was a flavor explosion, while the Margherita offered classic simplicity with fresh, local ingredients. The large portions ensured our group left full and happy, with slices to spare.

The Saffron Risotto Balls were a revelation as a side. Crispy on the outside, they ooze smoked scamorza and peas, delivering a luxurious texture that had me savoring every morsel. The fresh marinara dip added a zesty kick, showcasing the kitchen’s attention to detail.

The staff’s genuine warmth and professionalism made the evening shine. They offered wine pairings with a smile and checked in just enough to feel attentive without hovering, creating a relaxed, joyful vibe. Their care transformed a meal into a memory.

Piazza 1909 is a must-try for anyone craving bold, authentic pizza in La Jolla. Its unique toppings, generous servings, and stellar service make it ideal for locals and tourists alike. Visit for a slice of history and flavor you won’t forget!

Regents Pizzeria

Address: 4150 Regents Park Row #100, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-550-0406
Website: regentspizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 10 PM daily

Highlights:

Chicago and New York-style pizzas for diverse tastes
Craft beer selection with 30 rotating taps
Large portions ideal for casual gatherings
Spicy wings as a fiery sidekick
Lively, welcoming service in a laid-back vibe

What’s the secret to pizza that feels like a party? At Regents Pizzeria, my #3 toplist pick, I walked into a vibrant, casual space filled with the hoppy aroma of craft beer and sizzling dough. The bustling energy and neon signs created an inviting, fun vibe perfect for a night out.

The pizzas are bold and satisfying, with options for every craving. The Chicago-style Meat Lovers, with its thick, buttery crust and hearty toppings, was a decadent treat, while the New York-style Pepperoni offered crisp, foldable slices with zesty sauce. The generous portions meant our group of four had plenty to share and enjoy.

The Spicy Wings were a standout side, crisp and fiery with a house-made sauce that packed a punch. The high-quality chicken and perfect seasoning left me impressed, dipping each bite into creamy ranch for balance.

The staff were energetic and engaging, recommending beers to pair with our pizzas and keeping the vibe upbeat. Their quick responses to our requests, like extra napkins, made us feel right at home in the lively atmosphere.

Regents Pizzeria is a go-to for hearty pizza and good times in La Jolla. With diverse styles, big portions, and top-notch service, it’s perfect for locals and visitors craving a fun meal. Grab a slice and a beer you’ll leave smiling!

Dough Momma Pizzeria

Address: 2152 Avenida De La Playa, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-246-6692
Website: doughmommapizzeria.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily

Highlights:

Artisanal pizzas with locally sourced ingredients
Creative toppings, like BBQ chicken, for adventurous eaters
Satisfying portions for beachside feasts
Garlic knots that steal the show
Welcoming, attentive service near the shore

Craving pizza with a beachy twist? Dough Momma Pizzeria, my #4 toplist favorite, welcomed me with a cozy, surf-inspired vibe just steps from La Jolla Shores. The salty breeze and fresh dough aroma created a relaxed, seaside charm that felt like home.

The pizzas are exceptional, with a crisp yet chewy crust that’s pure comfort. The BBQ Chicken pizza, with its tangy sauce and smoky mozzarella, was a creative standout, while the Classic Margherita showcased vibrant, local tomatoes. The hearty portions ensured our beach crew left full and content.

The Garlic Knots were a side dish to remember. Soft, warm, and herb-infused, they’re perfectly seasoned and served with a zesty marinara that had me savoring every bite. The fresh ingredients made each knot a tiny burst of joy.

The staff’s friendly, down-to-earth demeanor made us feel like regulars. They offered thoughtful suggestions, like pairing our pizza with a local IPA, and their prompt service kept the meal flowing smoothly, enhancing the carefree vibe.

For creative, satisfying pizza near the beach, Dough Momma is a top choice in La Jolla. Its fresh ingredients, generous portions, and warm service make it a must for locals and tourists. Stop by after a surf session for a meal that hits all the right spots!

Catania

Address: 7863 Girard Ave #301, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-551-5105
Website: cataniasd.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8:30 PM daily

Highlights:

Wood-fired pizzas with premium ingredients
Unique Sicilian pistachio pizza for bold palates
Ample portions for a luxurious meal
Decadent meatballs as a savory side
Polished, attentive service with a smile

What elevates a pizza to fine dining? At Catania, my #5 toplist gem, I entered a sleek, rooftop oasis with stunning views of La Jolla’s village. The elegant yet approachable space, with its open patio, felt inviting and refined, setting the stage for a memorable meal.

The pizzas are masterfully crafted, with a wood-fired crust that’s crisp and aromatic. The Sicilian Pistachio pizza, with its nutty, creamy topping, was a daring, delicious surprise, while the Margherita delivered classic perfection with bright, fresh flavors. The large portions left our table impressed and fully satisfied.

The Meatballs were a standout side, juicy and tender with a rich, house-made marinara. The high-quality beef and perfect seasoning had me savoring each bite, marveling at their comforting depth of flavor.

The staff were polished and genuinely warm, offering wine pairings and checking in with quiet efficiency. Their attentive care, like refilling drinks without prompting, made the experience feel luxurious yet relaxed.

Catania is a top-tier choice for elevated pizza in La Jolla. Its unique flavors, hearty portions, and impeccable service make it perfect for locals and visitors seeking a refined meal. Visit for a rooftop escape and pizza that wows!

Pizza on Pearl

Address: 617 Pearl St, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-729-0717
Website: pizzaonpearl.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Classic New York-style pizzas with foldable slices
Robust pepperoni for traditionalists
Generous portions for budget-friendly meals
Garlic knots that are pure comfort
Friendly, efficient service in a casual setting

Can a no-frills pizzeria steal your heart? Pizza on Pearl, my #6 toplist pick, welcomed me into a warm, unpretentious space with the comforting scent of baking dough. The laid-back vibe and checkered tablecloths felt like a nostalgic hug, perfect for a quick bite.

The pizzas are reliably delicious, with a thin, crispy New York-style crust. The Pepperoni, with its bold, spicy kick, was a crowd-pleaser, while the Veggie offered fresh, colorful toppings that popped with flavor. The hefty portions made it a great value, leaving us full for hours.

The Garlic Knots were a side dish gem, golden and chewy with a buttery, garlicky glaze. Dipped in tangy marinara, they were irresistibly comforting, showcasing the kitchen’s knack for simple perfection.

The staff were cheerful and efficient, delivering our order with a smile and checking in just enough to feel caring. Their quick service kept the meal seamless, enhancing the easygoing charm of the place.

Pizza on Pearl is a go-to for classic, affordable pizza in La Jolla. Its satisfying slices, generous portions, and friendly vibe make it ideal for locals and tourists. Drop in for a slice of nostalgia and leave with a happy belly!

Piatti

Address: 2182 Avenida De La Playa, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-454-1589
Website: piatti.com
Hours: Open from 10 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Wood-fired pizzas with coastal Italian flair
Herbed cauliflower cakes as a unique side
Satisfying portions for beachside dining
Fresh, local ingredients in every bite
Attentive, warm service in a charming setting

What’s the recipe for pizza with a coastal soul? At Piatti, my #7 toplist gem, I stepped into a bright, airy space near La Jolla Shores, with a covered patio that felt inviting and serene. The fresh bread and olive oil on the table set a welcoming tone.

The pizzas are vibrant and flavorful, with a wood-fired crust that’s crisp yet tender. The Pappardelle with Shrimp pizza, a creative twist, was a seafood lover’s dream, while the Margherita shone with bright, local tomatoes. The generous portions ensured our beach day ended on a full note.

The Herbed Cauliflower Cakes were a standout side, crisp outside and tender within, served with a zesty aioli. The fresh herbs and perfect seasoning left me impressed, craving another order before I’d finished the first.

The staff were gracious and attentive, offering menu insights and ensuring our drinks stayed filled. Their warm hospitality made us feel like valued guests, elevating the relaxed, coastal vibe.

Piatti is a must-visit for fresh, flavorful pizza in La Jolla. Its local ingredients, hearty portions, and stellar service make it perfect for locals and tourists. Enjoy a meal here after a beach day for a true taste of the coast!

House of Pizza

Address: 8107 Camino Del Sol, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-246-7200
Website: houseofpizzalj.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily

Highlights:

Classic pizzas with a homemade touch
Spicy sausage topping for bold flavor
Affordable, hearty portions for families
Cheesy garlic bread as a crowd-pleasing side
Friendly, neighborhood service

Can a neighborhood joint deliver pizza perfection? House of Pizza, my #8 toplist pick, welcomed me into a cozy, family-friendly space with the comforting aroma of baking crust. The simple, homey decor felt like a warm embrace from La Jolla’s heart.

The pizzas are consistently delicious, with a thick, chewy crust that’s made fresh daily. The Spicy Sausage pizza, with its fiery kick, was a bold standout, while the Cheese option offered gooey, classic comfort. The large portions were perfect for our family gathering, with plenty to go around.

The Cheesy Garlic Bread was a side dish star, golden and melty with a buttery, garlicky crust. Paired with house marinara, it was irresistibly indulgent, leaving us grinning with every bite.

The staff were kind and approachable, treating us like neighbors with their genuine smiles. Their prompt service and care for our kids’ requests made the meal heartwarming and stress-free.

House of Pizza is a hidden gem for classic, affordable pizza in La Jolla. Its hearty portions, homemade flavors, and friendly vibe make it a top pick for locals and families. Stop by for a slice of community and comfort!

Wheat & Water

Address: 7408 La Jolla Blvd, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: 858-459-1400
Website: wheatandwater.com
Hours: Open from 4 PM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Wood-fired pizzas with seasonal toppings
Wild mushroom pizza for earthy depth
Generous portions for sharing
Charcuterie board as a sophisticated side
Lively, attentive service in a trendy setting

What makes a pizza feel like a seasonal celebration? Wheat & Water, my #9 toplist pick, drew me into a trendy, vibrant space with exposed brick and the smoky scent of wood-fired ovens. The lively patio felt like La Jolla’s cool heart.

The pizzas are artfully crafted, with a crisp, charred crust. The Wild Mushroom pizza, with its earthy truffle notes, was a flavorful masterpiece, while the Margherita offered bright, fresh simplicity. The hefty portions ensured our group savored every bite and still had leftovers.

The Charcuterie Board was a standout side, featuring artisan cheeses and cured meats arranged with care. The fresh accompaniments, like figs and nuts, created a sophisticated balance that left me impressed and craving more.

The staff were engaging and attentive, suggesting cocktail pairings and keeping our table lively. Their thoughtful check-ins and enthusiasm made the meal feel like a celebration of good food and company.

Wheat & Water is a top spot for seasonal, bold pizza in La Jolla. Its creative toppings, generous portions, and vibrant service make it a must for locals and visitors. Visit for a trendy, flavorful escape!

American Pizza Manufacturing

Address: 4550 La Jolla Village Dr, San Diego, CA 92122
Phone: 858-246-6756
Website: apmsd.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

New York and Chicago-style pizzas with bold flavors
Meatball ricotta pizza for indulgent cravings
Large portions for group dining
Crispy calamari as a delightful side
Efficient, friendly service in a modern setting

Can a mall pizzeria rival La Jolla’s best? American Pizza Manufacturing, my #10 toplist pick, surprised me with a modern, sleek space in UTC, where the savory aroma of baking pizza created a welcoming buzz. The open layout felt accessible yet polished.

The pizzas are robust and flavorful, with options for every taste. The Meatball Ricotta pizza, with its creamy, savory topping, was an indulgent delight, while the New York-style Cheese offered crisp, classic perfection. The generous portions made it ideal for our group, with slices to spare.

The Crispy Calamari was a standout side, lightly fried and perfectly tender, served with a zesty marinara. The fresh seafood quality had me savoring each bite, impressed by the attention to detail.

The staff were friendly and efficient, delivering our order quickly and offering helpful suggestions for drink pairings. Their polished service kept the meal seamless, enhancing the lively, modern vibe.

American Pizza Manufacturing is a surprising gem for bold, satisfying pizza in La Jolla. Its hearty portions, creative toppings, and great service make it a top choice for locals and shoppers. Stop by for a slice that overdelivers!

Savoring La Jolla’s Finest Slices: Your Next Stop Awaits

My journey through La Jolla’s top 10 pizza havens reveals a vibrant tapestry of flavors, from Isola Pizza Bar’s authentic Neapolitan pies to American Pizza Manufacturing’s bold meatball ricotta. Each spot shines with unique toppings, generous portions, and heartfelt service, making them must-visits for pizza lovers. Whether you’re drawn to cozy patios or trendy rooftops, these restaurants promise meals that linger in memory. San Diego Nav invites you to explore these gems, grab a slice, and discover why La Jolla’s pizza scene is a culinary treasure for locals and travelers alike.