The Absolute Best Pizza in La Jolla, San Diego: Must-Try Pies

As a La Jolla native, I’ve spent years savoring slices across this sunny coastal town, chasing the perfect pizza experience. The best pizza in La Jolla, San Diego, isn’t just about gooey cheese or crispy crust; it’s about vibrant flavors, welcoming vibes, and memories made over shared pies.

From wood-fired Neapolitan to bold New York-style, La Jolla’s pizzerias offer something for every palate. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, these top 10 spots promise unforgettable meals that capture the heart of our beachside community. Join me as I dive into each restaurant, sharing personal insights, must-try dishes, and why they shine on this toplist.

Top 10 Best Pizza Restaurants in La Jolla, San Diego

As a La Jolla local, I’ve explored countless pizza joints in this coastal gem, chasing the perfect slice. From wood-fired Neapolitan to classic New York-style, these top 10 pizzerias stand out for their quality, creativity, and unforgettable flavors. Each spot offers a unique experience, blending fresh ingredients, vibrant atmospheres, and stellar service. Below, I share my personal experiences at these restaurants, complete with essential details and highlights that make them shine in La Jolla’s culinary scene.

Isola Pizza Bar

Address: 7734 Girard Ave, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 412-5566
Website: isolapizzabar.com
Hours: Open from 11:30 AM to 10 PM daily

Highlights:

Authentic Neapolitan pizza baked in imported wood-fired ovens
Homemade ingredients, including tangy tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella
Cozy outdoor patio perfect for sunny lunches or starry dinners
Curated wine list featuring Italian selections from Piemonte
Attentive service that feels like family

What makes a pizza experience truly unforgettable? Stepping into Isola Pizza Bar, I’m greeted by a warm, inviting ambiance, with the aroma of wood-fired dough wafting through the air. Ranked #1 on our toplist, this gem captures the essence of Naples in La Jolla’s heart. The rustic charm of the indoor-outdoor space sets the stage for a meal that feels like a mini-vacation to Italy.

The pizzas here are nothing short of spectacular. The Margherita boasts a perfectly blistered crust with a balance of sweet San Marzano tomatoes and creamy mozzarella, while the Salsiccia dazzles with fennel sausage and a bold, savory kick. These pies are masterpieces, with generous portions that leave you satisfied yet craving more. The thin, chewy crust is a testament to their craft, making every bite a delight.

Don’t skip the arancini, a standout side. These golden, crispy rice balls are stuffed with gooey mozzarella and served with a vibrant marinara that pops with freshness. The crunchy exterior gives way to a melt-in-your-mouth center, leaving me in awe of their execution. It’s a small dish that packs a big punch.

The staff elevates the experience with genuine warmth and impeccable knowledge. They’re quick to suggest pairings, like a glass of Piemonte red to complement the pizza, and their attentiveness ensures every need is met. On my last visit, they seamlessly accommodated a request for extra basil, making the meal feel personalized.

For locals and tourists alike, Isola Pizza Bar is a must-visit. Its authentic flavors, generous portions, and stellar service make it a standout on our toplist. Whether you’re craving a romantic dinner or a casual slice by the beach, this pizzeria delivers an unforgettable experience. Come savor a slice of Italy in La Jolla.

Regents Pizzeria

Address: 4150 Regents Park Row #100, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 550-0406
Website: regentspizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Chicago and New York-style pizzas for diverse cravings
30 craft beer taps with rotating selections
Spacious dining area ideal for groups
Generous portions perfect for sharing
Efficient delivery within a 5-mile radius

Can a pizzeria feel like a lively neighborhood hangout? Regents Pizzeria, #2 on our toplist, welcomes me with a bustling, cheerful vibe, where the scent of freshly baked dough and hoppy craft beer fills the air. The open, casual space invites everyone from families to beer enthusiasts.

The pizzas here are bold and satisfying. The Chicago-style Meat Lovers is a hearty masterpiece, layered with sausage, pepperoni, and a thick, buttery crust that holds up beautifully. For a lighter option, the New York-style Veggie impresses with crisp vegetables and a tangy sauce that sings. Portions are massive, ensuring no one leaves hungry, and the quality keeps me coming back.

The garlic knots, dubbed “love nuggets,” steal the show as a side. These pillowy, golden bites are brushed with garlic butter and served with a zesty marinara. Their soft, chewy texture and burst of flavor make them irresistible, pairing perfectly with the pizzas.

Service is friendly and efficient, with staff who are passionate about their craft. They’re quick to recommend beers to match your pie, and their welcoming demeanor makes dining here feel like a gathering with friends. On one visit, they handled a large group order with ease, keeping everyone happy.

Regents Pizzeria is a top pick for anyone seeking hearty pizzas, great beer, and a lively atmosphere. Its spot on our toplist is well-earned, making it ideal for casual dinners or group outings in La Jolla. Stop by and indulge in a slice of comfort.

Dough Momma Pizzeria

Address: 2152 Avenida De La Playa, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 246-6692
Website: doughmommapizzeria.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Creative pizza toppings for adventurous eaters
By-the-slice options for quick bites
Fun, lively indoor space with a beachy vibe
Vegetarian-friendly menu with fresh ingredients
Welcoming staff who enhance the experience

What’s the secret to a perfect beachside pizza? At Dough Momma Pizzeria, ranked #3, I’m instantly drawn into a vibrant, laid-back space where the salty ocean breeze mingles with the aroma of baking crust. This La Jolla Shores spot feels like a coastal retreat.

The pizzas are innovative and delicious. The BBQ Chicken pie blends sweet-tangy sauce with tender chicken and red onions, creating a flavor explosion. The Margherita, with its fresh basil and velvety mozzarella, is a classic done right. Portions are generous, making it easy to share or savor leftovers.

The caesar salad is a standout side, served with crisp romaine, house-made dressing, and buttery croutons. The creamy, tangy dressing elevates the dish, and the freshness of the greens leaves me impressed. It’s a refreshing complement to the rich pizzas.

The staff’s enthusiasm and attentiveness make every visit special. They’re eager to explain the menu and quick to accommodate requests, like swapping toppings for dietary needs. Their warm smiles create a homey feel that’s hard to beat.

For a fun, flavorful pizza experience, Dough Momma Pizzeria is a La Jolla gem. Its creative pies, fresh sides, and friendly vibe secure its place on our toplist. Whether you’re a local or visiting, grab a slice and enjoy the coastal charm.

Pizza on Pearl

Address: 617 Pearl St, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 729-0717
Website: pizzaonpearl.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily

Highlights:

Classic New York-style pizza with a crispy crust
Garlic knots that are a fan favorite
Rustic, cozy ambiance perfect for casual dining
Fresh, locally sourced ingredients in every dish
Fast, friendly service for dine-in or takeout

Is there anything better than a classic slice? Pizza on Pearl, #4 on our toplist, envelops me in a warm, nostalgic atmosphere, with the scent of bubbling cheese and a charming, rustic interior. This spot feels like a slice of home in La Jolla.

The pizzas are consistently excellent. The Pepperoni delivers a crisp, thin crust topped with spicy, curled pepperoni and rich sauce, while the Veggie shines with colorful peppers and mushrooms. Portions are plentiful, ideal for a satisfying meal or sharing with friends.

The garlic knots are a must-try side. These chewy, golden nuggets are drizzled with garlic oil and served with a robust marinara. Their buttery, savory bite is addictive, making them a perfect starter.

Service is prompt and cheerful, with staff who are eager to please. They handle busy crowds with ease and always offer a friendly greeting, making every visit enjoyable. They once rushed a takeout order for me without sacrificing quality.

Pizza on Pearl is a go-to for classic pizza lovers. Its fresh ingredients, tasty sides, and welcoming vibe make it a toplist favorite. Locals and visitors should swing by for a timeless slice in La Jolla.

Catania

Address: 7863 Girard Ave, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 551-5505
Website: cataniasd.com
Hours: Open from 11:30 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Wood-fired Sicilian pizzas with bold flavors
Elegant, coastal-inspired dining space
Handmade pastas as a unique side offering
Craft cocktails that elevate the meal
Knowledgeable staff who enhance the experience

Can a pizzeria feel like a fine-dining escape? Catania, #5 on our toplist, greets me with a sleek, sophisticated ambiance, where the glow of wood-fired ovens and ocean-inspired decor create a luxurious vibe. This downtown La Jolla spot is a culinary haven.

The pizzas are exquisite. The Sicilian Pistachio is a creative triumph, blending nutty pistachio cream with mozzarella and a crisp crust, while the Margherita offers vibrant tomatoes and silky cheese. Portions are perfectly sized, leaving room to explore the menu.

The crudo appetizer is a revelation. This delicate raw fish dish, adorned with citrus and herbs, is melt-in-your-mouth fresh. The bright, zesty flavors make every bite unforgettable, showcasing the kitchen’s finesse.

The staff is polished yet approachable, offering expert recommendations on wine or cocktail pairings. Their attention to detail, like ensuring my pizza was piping hot, elevates the experience. They make dining feel effortlessly special.

Catania is a toplist star for its refined pizzas, stunning sides, and impeccable service. It’s a must for foodies and travelers seeking a memorable meal in La Jolla. Treat yourself to this coastal gem.

Piazza 1909

Address: 7731 Fay Ave, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 412-3108
Website: piazza1909.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Authentic Italian recipes from Milan
Generous portions for hearty appetites
Charming beach house setting with history
Fresh, house-made pastas alongside pizzas
Attentive, family-like service

What’s it like to dine in a historic beach house? Piazza 1909, #6 on our toplist, welcomes me with a cozy, nostalgic charm, its restored interiors and aroma of simmering sauce creating an inviting escape. This La Jolla spot feels like stepping into Italy.

The pizzas are robust and flavorful. The Sausage and Peppers pie combines spicy sausage with sweet bell peppers on a chewy crust, while the Quattro Formaggi melts four cheeses into creamy perfection. Portions are hearty, ensuring a fulfilling meal.

The meatballs are a standout side, simmered in rich marinara and tender enough to cut with a fork. Their savory, comforting flavor is pure bliss, making them a must-order alongside the pizza.

Service is warm and attentive, with staff who treat you like family. They’re quick to share stories about the menu’s Milanese roots, adding a personal touch. They once customized a pizza for my friend’s dietary needs flawlessly.

Piazza 1909 earns its toplist spot with authentic dishes, generous portions, and heartfelt service. It’s a fantastic choice for locals and visitors craving Italian comfort in La Jolla. Come for a meal that warms the soul.

Wheat & Water

Address: 5737 La Jolla Blvd, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 291-8287
Website: wheatandwater.com
Hours: Open from 4 PM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Award-winning wood-fired pizzas with premium ingredients
Local craft beer selection for perfect pairings
Sleek, modern vibe with a lively atmosphere
Kale Caesar salad as a fresh side option
Friendly, engaging staff

Can a pizzeria blend modern flair with classic comfort? Wheat & Water, #7 on our toplist, captivates with a trendy, energetic space, where the crackle of wood-fired ovens and hoppy beer aromas set a lively tone. This Bird Rock gem is a local favorite.

The pizzas are phenomenal. The Wild Mushroom pie, with its earthy truffle notes and creamy cheese, is a flavor bomb, while the Pepperoni delivers crisp, spicy bites on a perfect crust. Portions are satisfying, ideal for a night out.

The kale Caesar salad is a refreshing side, with crisp kale, tangy dressing, and parmesan shavings. Its vibrant crunch and bold flavors make it a standout, balancing the richness of the pizzas.

The staff is engaging and knowledgeable, offering beer pairing suggestions with enthusiasm. Their quick service and genuine smiles make dining here a joy. They once ensured my order was rushed for a tight schedule.

Wheat & Water is a toplist must for its stellar pizzas, fresh sides, and vibrant vibe. Locals and tourists will love this modern pizzeria in La Jolla. Stop by for a meal that hits all the right spots.

American Pizza Manufacturing

Address: 7408 La Jolla Blvd, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 459-1400
Website: apmsd.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 8 PM daily

Highlights:

Top-rated Margherita pizza with fresh tomatoes
Prime corner location near the beach
Quick, no-frills service for takeout lovers
Locally sourced ingredients for quality
Affordable prices for budget diners

Is a simple slice sometimes the best? American Pizza Manufacturing, #8 on our toplist, greets me with a breezy, no-fuss vibe, its prime beachside spot and fresh dough scent creating a laid-back charm. This La Jolla Boulevard staple is all about quality.

The pizzas are fresh and reliable. The Margherita shines with juicy, local tomatoes and a light, crispy crust, while the Sausage offers bold fennel flavors and melty cheese. Portions are just right, perfect for a quick beachside meal.

The side salad is a gem, with crisp greens, cherry tomatoes, and a zesty vinaigrette. Its fresh, vibrant bite is surprisingly delightful, making it a great pizza partner.

Service is fast and friendly, with staff who keep things moving. They’re efficient for takeout orders and always offer a warm greeting, making you feel welcome. They once had my order ready in record time.

American Pizza Manufacturing is a toplist pick for fresh, affordable pizzas and beachside convenience. It’s ideal for locals and travelers seeking a quick, tasty slice in La Jolla. Grab a pie and hit the shore.

Leucadia Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Address: 7748 Regents Rd, La Jolla, CA 92122
Phone: (858) 597-2222
Website: leucadiapizza.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Unique sweet crust for a distinctive bite
Extensive Italian menu beyond pizza
Family-friendly vibe with casual charm
Efficient delivery service for convenience
Fresh, high-quality toppings

What makes a pizzeria a community staple? Leucadia Pizzeria, #9 on our toplist, wraps me in a homey, welcoming atmosphere, with the aroma of baking dough and a cozy, family-friendly space. This La Jolla spot is a local legend.

The pizzas are delightfully unique. The BBQ Chicken pie, with its sweet crust and tangy sauce, is a crowd-pleaser, while the Pesto Veggie bursts with fresh spinach and artichokes. Portions are generous, perfect for family dinners.

The Caesar salad stands out, with crisp romaine, creamy dressing, and garlic croutons. Its fresh, bold flavors are expertly balanced, making it a refreshing side that complements the pizzas.

Service is courteous and attentive, with staff who treat you like regulars. They’re quick to customize orders and keep the vibe upbeat. They once handled a large delivery order for me flawlessly.

Leucadia Pizzeria earns its toplist spot with unique pizzas, fresh sides, and community charm. It’s a top choice for locals and visitors craving Italian comfort in La Jolla. Come for a meal that feels like home.

Carino’s Restaurant

Address: 7408 La Jolla Blvd, La Jolla, CA 92037
Phone: (858) 459-1400
Website: carinosrestaurant.com
Hours: Open from 11 AM to 9 PM daily

Highlights:

Hidden gem status with top-tier pizzas
Warm, intimate setting for cozy dining
Fresh, homemade sauces for authentic flavor
Attentive staff who make you feel special
Affordable menu for value-driven diners

Can a small spot steal your heart with pizza? Carino’s Restaurant, #10 on our toplist, enchants with an intimate, cozy ambiance, where the scent of homemade sauce and soft lighting create a heartwarming escape. This La Jolla hidden gem is pure magic.

The pizzas are outstanding. The Spicy Sausage pie, with its fiery peppers and rich mozzarella, is a flavor powerhouse, while the Margherita offers fresh basil and a delicate crust. Portions are satisfying, leaving you content and happy.

The bruschetta is a stellar side, with toasted bread topped with juicy tomatoes, garlic, and olive oil. Its bright, fresh taste is pure joy, making it a perfect starter for the meal.

Service is exceptional, with staff who are genuinely passionate. They’re quick to offer recommendations and make every guest feel special, like when they remembered my favorite pizza on a return visit. Their warmth is unmatched.

Carino’s Restaurant is a toplist treasure for its flavorful pizzas, fresh sides, and heartfelt service. Locals and tourists should seek out this hidden gem in La Jolla for a memorable meal. Come discover why it’s a local secret.

Savoring La Jolla’s Pizza Scene

This toplist of the best pizza in La Jolla, San Diego, showcases 10 pizzerias that elevate dining with fresh ingredients, creative recipes, and stellar service. From Isola Pizza Bar’s authentic Neapolitan pies to Carino’s cozy, hidden-gem charm, each spot offers unique flavors and warm atmospheres. Locals and tourists alike will find generous portions, vibrant sides, and staff who make every visit special. For the ultimate pizza adventure, use San Diego Nav to explore these culinary treasures. Grab a slice, soak in La Jolla’s coastal magic, and discover why these restaurants are must-visits on your foodie journey.